He was killed with far greater compassion though., Carlson killing Candys dog leaves Candy wishing hed done it himself, whereas when George killed Lennie, he isnt left with guilt. (one code per order). Carlson suggests shooting Candy's dog because he stinks. Why does George lie about the gun? After George, Lennie, and Candy make a pact not to tell anyone about their dream, Candy makes the following statement: "I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. Describe the conversation George and Lennie have after the men go in search of a fight between Cruley and Slim. Why isnt Curleys wifes name ever revealed? What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? How does his statement add to the violent nature of the novel? Share Cite. eNotes Editorial, 25 Jan. 2014, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/outline-all-the-reasons-why-carlson-wants-to-455632. Curley stated that he would shoot him if he found him and slim planned on locking Lennie up in a mental hospital if he found him alive. What is the significance of the killing of Candys dog and how does it mirror the killing of Lennie? 61). His dog enters later in chapter two, whom is described as a dragfooted sheepdog, gray of a muzzle, and with pale, old eyes(Steinbeck 26). These characters try to stop Carlson from shooting the dog, but they are not successful. Lastly, he states that the dog is "no good to himself". We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. play. I had him so long. Lennie scares the girl in the red dress in the town of Weed. What are Carlsons reasons for shooting Candys dog How could this incident foreshadow possible events to come? The skinner had been studying the old dog with his calm eyes. While this may have been true, it was clearly not the whole story. Carlsons shooting the dog humanely in the back of the head foreshadows the manner of Lennies death, and like Candy, who consents to putting his dog down, George experiences heartbreaking anguish in doing what must be done. Candy was heartbroken when Carlson shot her dog. Candy says that he should have shot the dog, and that "you shoot your own dog.". Why does Carlson want to shoot Candys dog How does Candy feel about this line support? "No, Lennie. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Carlson doesn't have a good reason; he's just a mean guy. Carlson says that he will shoot Candys dog in the back of the neck where the neck and head meet. Why did Candy agree to let Carlson shoot his old and sick dog? First, the dog is stiff with rheumatism. Second, Carlson says that the dog is no good for Candy. Why isnt Curleys wifes name ever revealed? Do George and Candy still plan to buy the dream farm after Lennies death? She searched for her dog for weeks, but he was never found. In order to kill Lennie, George would need a gun. Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. creating and saving your own notes as you read. Throughout the fight there are many animals references referring to either Lennie or Curley. How is Lennie different from the other men? Comment by evanhouty April 19, 2007 @ 10:56 am Reply Carlson. John Steinbeck and Of Mice and Men Background. Ever time he comes into the bunk house I can smell him for two, three days. Candy had to agree to let Carlson shoot his old dog because the author mandated it for plot purposes. What happens as a result of Lennie's taking care of himself? Everybody thinks it was Lennie who stole the Luger after he killed Curley's wife and fled from the ranch. She was mad at him for a long time, but eventually forgave him. He wants to keep his hand soft for his wife. I wisht somebodyd shoot me if I got old an a cripple, Slim presents an important symbolism behind Candys old dog. If he shots the dog at this place, he tells Candy that the dog won't feel anything.. George knew that Lennie would continue to get into trouble and maybe hurt more people, so did what was best for him. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. While these words may have been meant to comfort her, they only served to make her more upset. He relentlessly pursues the dogs death, more for his own comfort than to put the dog out of its misery. They could see how much pain Candy was in, and they wished they could have done something to help him. But the play could only run for about an hour and a half. Here is a video that describes Candy's character in-depth: Often when groups of the same gender live in close quarters with one another, there is a "pecking order" established; that is, the strongest--whether it be physical or mental dominance--is at the top, and the weakest at the bottom. Candy is introduced in the start of chapter two, he is described indirectly by the narrator as a Stoop shouldered old man(Steinbeck 18). Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. George describes to Lennie the sights, sounds, and smells of the farm they hope to someday own and the description interests Candy. Although Carlson promises to kill the dog painlessly, his insistence that the old animal must die supports a cruel natural law that the strong will dispose of the weak. Related Read: Why does my dog bite my other dogs neck? Stinks like hell, too. Carlson completely ignores any sentimental or affectionate feelings Candy might have for his dog and only focuses on the dogs uselessness, suffering, and inconvenience. What changes might an older person experience that would affect his or her clothing needs? Slim asks Carlson to take a shovel with him when he goes to shoot Candy's dog because he was being careful and understanding towards Candy's dog's death. Both deaths are acts of mercy. Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. Already a member? Why do you think George encourages Lennie to fight back when Curley hits him? Ill have thirty dollars more comin, time you guys is ready to quit.. You can have a pup if you want to. He seemed to shake himself free for speech. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? He thinks that Slim is with his wife. Finally, Carlson may have simply felt that it was the right thing to do. Quotes from Carlson, a ranch-hand, reveals this saying, "Whyn't you get Candy to shoot his old dog and give him one of the pups to raise up?, I can smell that dog a mile away., Got no teeth, damn near blind, can't eat. In "Of Mice and Men", Carlson shoots Candy's old, disabled dog because he believes that it is the humane thing to do. She knew that Carlson was not telling her the whole truth and that he was just trying to make himself feel better. Lennie is afraid that he has done something bad, but George reassures him that he hasn't. Because of his condition, he is unable to work alongside the other men and in turn feels lonely with only his dog to accompany him which is later euthanized as a result of, [Candy] said miserably, "You seen what they done to my dog tonight? Carlson offers to shoot the old dog, complaining many times of the smell. Candy was heartbroken. Related Read: Why is my dog eating frozen dog poop? Accessed 1 May 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. John Steinbeck had to work out the plot for his novel before writing it. The dream they share gives them something to help them survive. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? "You tried to throw a scare into Slim, an' you couldn't make it stick. "That stink hangs around even after he's gone." Third, the dog does not have any teeth. When they can me here I wisht somebodyd shoot me. He told Lennie to think of the land and the rabbit, then shot him right in the spine and neck to cause instantaneous, painless death. I dont know nothing that stinks as bad as an old dog. Carlson says the dog aint no good to Candy, unable to see that the dog still has value as Candys friend and companion. Want 100 or more? Continuing to protect him, George made sure Lennie had no pain while killing him. "Got no teeth," he said. He didn't want to shoot his dog because of that reason too. It is old and can no longer walk, meaning that it is likely only going to get worse as time goes on. Why does Candy say that he should have shot his dog himself instead of letting a stranger do it? Here, Candys dog once again symbolizes the fear and realities of an aging farm worker. George agrees and with Candy's investment, which is half the cost of the ranch George described, the dream becomes more tangible. How do the descriptions of Curley change throughout the fight? As Lennie and George are introduced to the bunkhouse, Carlson, one of the ranch workers, starts a conversation with Slim about Candys old dog. In John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men, who actually steals Carlson's gun? Carlson shoots Candy's dog because it is old, sick, and no longer able to work as a sheep dog. If George had not killed Lennie, he knew someone else would in a more painful way. first event. After Carlson's many pushes to have Candy shoot his old dog, Slim, the skinner, whose "opinions were law," speaks up and agrees with Carlson, encouraging Candy to accept the old dog's fate. Any action you take based on the information found on nahf.org is strictly at your discretion. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! Carlson keeps the handgun partly as a souvenir and partly for protection. Why is the man in the magazine? You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. What is the relationship between Candy and his dog? The dog and its weakness is a symbolism Steinbeck used to compare to Candy and his missing hand. For example, he was only close to his dog before he met George and Lennie and he was so eager to meet them and make friends. Get him outa here, Candy! We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. Please wait while we process your payment. The dog is seen as useless and smelly, therefore it was seen as more of a nuisance to Carlson and the others in the bunk house. Here, Candys dog symbolizes Candy as an old man and the effects of getting older. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? What is Carlsons solution to the problem of the dog? However, much like Candys old dog, once ranch workers could not work, they would lose their ability to provide for themselves or have a purpose in life, being quickly replaced by younger, more physically able workers. But the real reason is that Steinbeck needed to show the gun to George and to let him see how it worked and hear where to point it. ( Pgs. - All Animals Faq, Why Does Carlson Shoot Candy's Dog - All Animals Faq, Why Does Carlson Want To Shoot Candy's Dog - All Animals Faq. He is an outcast and is discriminated against. A ranch workers life during this time period was determined by his usefulness, and survival was directly linked to his ability to physically work. Candy was clearly attached to his dog and was devastated by its death. Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. Want 100 or more? Candy is reluctant to have his dog killed, but Carlson argues that the dog is in pain and that it would be better for the animal to be put out of its misery. What is Carlsons problem with Candys dog? He seemed to shake himself free for speech. SparkNotes Plus subscription is $4.99/month or $24.99/year as selected above. When they can me here I wisht somebody'd shoot me. First of all, he says that the dog . The dog is too old to be of any use and stinks up the room. George and Lennie, who remain behind, begin to discuss their future farm. Candy response was "You seen what they done to my dog tonight? $24.99 While Carlson is speaking to Slim (in chapter two of John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men), he states the many reasons that Candy's dog needs to be put down. This causes Candy to become even more lonely and isolated. He is also bitter that he has gotten stuck in a job he hates. Evaluate each of the special sewing techniques used in the project. Got no teeth, damn near blind, cant eat.[]. Thanks for creating a SparkNotes account! Everything that happens happens because the author decided to make it happen. Another possibility is that Carlson may have had it out for Candy personally and saw shooting his dog as a way to get back at him. After Carlsons many pushes to have Candy shoot his old dog, Slim, the skinner, whose opinions were law, speaks up and agrees with Carlson, encouraging Candy to accept the old dogs fate. I wisht somebodyd shoot me if I got old an a cripple, Slim presents an important symbolism behind Candys old dog. By the time Lennie finally relaxes his grip, Curley's hand has been ruined. Carlson is a bitter man. Candy takes an immediate dislike to the Old Dog and openly expresses this to Carlson. Continue to start your free trial. He wont know what hit him. Because it stinks and it is in pain, old, miserable ( crippled ), What are Candy's reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog? Members will be prompted to log in or create an account to redeem their group membership. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. The exact reason is never mentioned. Carlson explains to Candy exactly why the old dog should be put out of its misery. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime. As Carlson describes Candys dog as so God damn old he cant hardly walk and that he [s]tinks like hell, too, Carlson is trying to convince Slim to agree with him and persuade Candy to shoot his old dog. Through this description, Candys dog symbolizes how old age and decline are viewed by the ranch workers of this time period. The closest thing to friendship Candy possessed was the bond him and his dog shared. He has no one that cares to help him when he gets canned off the ranch. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. At the end of the novel, George kills Lennie in much the same way as Carlson kills Candys dog. 20% You can argue that his reasons are partly good and partly just selfish and mean. On the simplest level, Candy doesnt want to kill his dog because he loves it and remembers lots of great times they had together. ). He is a terrible person and Candy's dog deserved better. Whynt you shoot him, Candy?. By killing Lennie himself, George isnt left with guilt or regret. Discount, Discount Code He would only allow himself to do something; Lennie and the dog both need someone else to survive with and both grew up with either George or Candy when they were younger. Candy also had a close relationship with his dog. Question: Why Does Carlson Shoot Candys Dog, Quick Answer: When Carlson Starts To Take Candys Dog Out, Quick Answer: Is Bamboo Shoot Bad For Dog. The characters provide information for the reader and the future audience through their dialogue. Why do George and Lennie travel together? Because Candy knows his dog is not good to shoot and he wouldn't want to be responsible for killing him. One thing he probably had in mind at the outset was that he wanted to end the story with one man killing his friend out of compassion. Why is the killing of Candys dog a significant incident in the novel. He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. What type of establishment is it? Candys dog wasn't in good health and Lennie killed Curly's wife and would be in trouble with the law. She loved that dog more than anything and couldn't believe that Carlson would do something like that. Are the best fabrics and workmanship always on the more expensive garments? What is Carlsons problem and what does he tell Candy to do? answer choices . Curley returns with Whit, Carlson and Slim. He wants to put the dog out of its missery.Candy didnt want him to do that becase hes been with this dog forever. Therefore he could not write a big panoramic novel about the lives of itinerant farm workers, traveling on freight trains, working out in the fields, and so on. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! This creates loneliness because he thinks of his future. Evaluating quality. Contact us One thing he probably had in mind at the outset was that he wanted to end the story with one man killing his friend out of compassion. In John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men, who actually steals Carlson's gun? In Of Mice and Men, how does Candy become involved in George and Lennie's "dream ranch". Candy says, "I don't mind takin care of him." (45). 502 Words 3 Pages Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. Lennie was a big, powerful man who would do anything George told him to do. I can smell that dog a mile away. Describe the nature of the argument between Curley and Slim. "Hes all stiff with rheumatism. And physically Lennie survives with George, Because Lennie is bigger than him and he picks fights with bigger people. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Candy cant stand up for his pet because Candy cant stand up for himself., After Carlson shot Candy's dog Candy tells George, "I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. How do the other men get involved in the argument? Slim throwed a scare into you. How is this important for the group of men? Did you know you can highlight text to take a note? Youve successfully purchased a group discount. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Ace your assignments with our guide to Of Mice and Men! Example: Lennie covered his face with his huge paws and bleated with terror. George even tries to reason with Carlson, explaining that the dog is old and helpless, but Carlson does not listen. As Candy hears about George and Lennies dream to own a little farm, he jumps at the chance to join in, describing where his enthusiasm comes from and why he has such a deep desire to feel useful and secure as he ages. What does Carlson killing Candys dog symbolize? She had raised him from a pup and he was her best friend. Central Idea Essay: Who Is to Blame for the Death of Curley's Wife? MARIA: Quieres 4\underline{\hspace{10pt}4\hspace{10pt}}4 al bsquetbol? Discuss why people purchase counterfeit goods and the impact this has on legal manufacturers. In an attempt to make her feel better, he told her that the dog "didn't feel a thing" and that it "didn't suffer." What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? He wrote a letter to the editor, praising the publication. Simple repairs. "That stink hangs around even after hes gone." Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? Counterfeit apparel and accessories are available in many cities at far lower prices than the authentic merchandise. The dog is unable to do anything for itself and Candy is struggling to care for it, meaning that Carlson may have thought that it would be better for everyone if the animal was put down. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Why does Lennie have a dead mouse in his pocket? He works alone because he cant work with the other guys. Carlson takes the dog outside, promising Slim that he will bury the corpse. Related Read: How to stop dog from biting other dogs' necks?
What Side Is Home Team Dugout In Softball, Articles W